Board Thread:Suggestions/@comment-25044955-20140707034741/@comment-24046900-20140710230243

Potateyo wrote:

I Have some criticism to the problems

FredeyFly wrote: Getting prickly pear for a fruit salad is bad enough, thats going to take a long while. Also, doesn't prickly pear cactus taste disgusting?'''Prickly pear catcus tastes great. They are insanely sweet.(Me: Okay, no arguement) I drank a concentrate of it and it tasted like bleh.It's the fruit, not the concetrate that is added (Me:Ditto)''' Then you have to get clay, onion shoots, and carrots. That is going to make simply getting the stuff for a fruit salad hard enough. Now you slammed a cooking 4 on it. The making of this is so hard, in my opinion it is obsolite.'''It's meant to be created from the by-products of farming. (Me:Thats basically like putting stuff for mulch in a salad) Oh and, a carrot, not a carrot leaf in a fruit salad?It is a carrot leaf (Me:Actually, in the recipie for fruit salad contains a carrot, tuna salad too.)  '''Whens the last time you ate a fruit salad with carrots, prickly pear fruits, and apples in it?

Fried chicken salad? You have GOT to be kidding me. We are basically putting a chicken drumstick COVERED in fats, IN A SALAD FOR GOD SAKE, is that how you make a cesar salad? If so I'm never eating one again. Oh, and did I mention this meaty fried concoction raises health? I don't get that. Whens the last time you ate a fried chicken salad?No critism here

Tuna salad is a bit too specific, because you HAVE to catch tuna. Also, whens the last time you ate a tuna salad? I wouldn't eat a raw tuna salad either.I agree

Onto the problems that are relevant to ALL the salads. Have you ever seen a carrot before not with the top cut off? Have you ever seen an onion? Onion leaves are INSANELY bitter.'''No, they are not. If you eat the tender white parts. (Me:Tender whiteparts? I thought that was what made it spicy. Eitherway, you DO NOT put the white parts into a salad as the bulk, there just isn't enough of it, and even if you used the entire stalk, it still wouldn't be enough to be considered a bulk.)'''The seedpods are even worse, they are very spicy. (Even though I chew like gum both sometimes, they taste good alone) You do NOT put them in a salad. Ever. Carrot tops are like a dandilion's stalk except thinner. I've never tasted one, so I can't say they taste bad though.Carrot leaves tastes like a mixture of carrots and cabbage Either way, you don't place either of these in a salad as the leafage or bulk of a salad. Furthermore, whats with the insane cooking levels needed for this? Putting a salad together is putting spinach, lettuce, and such in a bowl and mixing it. It's not that hard to do. You aren't making a michealgelo sculpture.Agreed If this is ever added(improbable) here are more criticism

All of the salads needs buffing

Also, Making fruit salad means going to desert and getting prickly pear, so it should be buffed, and i suggest changing the prickly pear component to 2 berries

For the chicken salad, fried chicken is disgusting when put into a salad. also, why is there a herb in the salad?I suggest replacing the fried chicken with cooked chicken.

For the tuna salad, There is only a net gain of 18 when you craft the ingredients together. and because of the loong crafting chains, nobody would want to use it. Maybe it can be replaced with a 'fish salad' but i think that means we have to add a salad for each and every fish in the game. So fish salads, not recommended.

For overall, Why do all the salads restore such a high amount of thirst? And why do chicken salad restore more thirst than fruit salad? I thought fruits contain higher amounts of water?

Also, for the custom salads,  The custom stews are okay as they do not require a crafting sequence, but the custom salad you have to add a name in the crafting sequence for 'EVERY EDIBLE ITEM IN THE GAME. '

Consider these issues before adding salads ADDITION: Salads add... null(Salads are a filler). This improves gameplay by nerfing stews, because salads are basically a stew in a different format, however, salads do not require water, a ladle, or a cauldron.

'CONCLUSION: Salads are a filler and/or a copy of stews. There is no point in adding this, as it adds nothing to the game. It has failed the ChiefWaffles test too.'