Board Thread:Suggestions/@comment-24343460-20140102234140/@comment-24108228-20140103234737

Firstly, thanks! It's nice to know people like my (or SurvivorMagma's, depending on how you look at it) suggestion.

Onto the herbal cake, you need to change some things. If people like the idea, I'll accept it as a new type of cake, but some of these stats need changing.

Firstly, the recipe. To keep with consistency, the stove top should be removed. The milk, eggs, and dough are crafted into a cake dough, with eggs being excluded depending on the poll above, and the order should be shuffled, just for consistency, leaving us with the new recipe of: Herb + Herb + Cake Dough = Herbal Cake Isn't that much more simple and nice to look at?

Onto the stats. Firstly, the 2x the restoration of berry pie should be removed. That comes to 1 hour, 35 minutes of food, from one cake (which you could probably buy for a handful of iron). It should probably be slightly less than a berry cake, considering berrys are a foodstuff and herbs are more of a healing item, therefore a cake made from them would be less hunger replenishing. I suggest 175 hunger, slightly less of that of a apple pie.

The health is also something that should be edited. It currently heals 50 health, compared to 40 of a herbal remedy. This should probably be nerfed. If we reduce the portions to 5, having 35 hunger restored per portion, we get a much more forgiving health restoration of 25, leaving the herbal remedy in its rightful place at the top. If you disagree with herbal remedies being better than healthy cakes, think of it this way. Herbal remedy is a medicine, herbal cake is a cake made of healthy ingredients.

The skill requirements need adding to. As it is a herbal remedy fused with a cake, it should have the skill requirements of both. I would advise adding 3 chemistry to the list of requirements.

So, the finished revised herbal cake is: Herb + Herb + Cake Dough = Herbal Cake Restores 175 hunger, and 25 health, with 5 portions. Requires 7 cooking and 3 chemistry to make. Should this be added? Yes No Personally, I dislike the idea. But if others like it, we will add it to the list of cakes.

And if your wondering about why I ignored your mushroom cake, Just poison the cake the old fashoned way for better results.